[Tig] A stupid 3:2 question

[timothy norman huber]

I've never heard of 24i before Rob.  24P and 23.98 are both  
progressive as far as I'm concerned.  The pulldown works from the  
fields to create a progressive image.

T


On Nov 7, 2007, at 8:38 PM, Robert Houllahan wrote:

> Thanks to Assimilate Inc. for supporting the TIG.
> ====
>
> Howday all,
>
> This has come up from time to time with our direct to disk recordings
> from our TK suites. If I capture SDI uncompressed into our G5 with a
> blackmagic card and use the pulldown removed codec, i.e. enable
> pulldown removal on the card, I have a 24fps quicktime file which I
> can put into FCP, etc but is it Progressive? I assume that it is
> still interlaced just at 24fps and that if I wanted it to be truly
> progressive I would have to de-interlace the file in AE or Shake,
> etc. am I wrong?



Timothy Norman Huber
Director of Strategic Accounts
Violin Memory, Inc
33 Wood Ave South
Iselin, NJ, 08830


http://www.violin-memory.com/index.cfm
timothyhuber at violin-memory.com


(Los Angeles)
640 Woodlawn Ave
Venice, CA 90291

310 795-6599 Cell